Do Employers Interview Best Candidates First? (2024)

When it comes to interviews, there's always a debate about whether being the first or last candidate interviewed is advantageous. We'll explore the strategies behind scheduling interviews and whether employers typically interview the best candidate first.

Do Employers Interview Best Candidate First?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to whether employers interview the best candidate first. The reality is that different employers, including top finance recruiters and financial services recruiters in London, have different strategies when it comes to the scheduling process. It’s important to remember that only the top candidates will be interviewed, and therefore there is something interesting about your experience that the hiring manager will be looking to touch upon within the interview.

The Case for Interviewing First

Some hiring managers may choose to interview the strongest candidates first. This can be advantageous for a number of reasons. By interviewing the top candidate early, employers can gauge other candidates' performances against the benchmark set by the best candidate. This can also help streamline the hiring process if the best candidate impresses the interviewer and is a clear fit for the position.

The Case for Interviewing Last

On the other hand, some employers, including top finance recruiters and financial services recruiters in London, may prefer to save the best for last. This can allow them to get a better understanding of the overall candidate pool and make it easier to identify the top candidate's strengths and weaknesses. By interviewing the best candidate last, employers can also ensure they have a lasting impression of the strongest contender, which may be useful during the decision-making process.

Other Factors

Many other factors, including input from top finance recruiters and financial services recruiters in London, can influence the order in which candidates are interviewed, such as scheduling conflicts, interviewer preferences, or internal processes. Therefore, it's important not to read too much into the order of your interview.

FAQs

To help you navigate the often complex world of interviews, we've answered some commonly asked questions.

Does Being Interviewed First Mean Anything?

Being interviewed first doesn't necessarily indicate your standing as a candidate. It's important to remember that there are many reasons why an employer may schedule interviews in a certain order, and it's often unrelated to the perceived quality of the candidates.

Does the Order of Your Interview Matter?

While the order of your interview may have some impact on how your performance is assessed, it's crucial to focus on what you can control: presenting your skills, experience, and personality in the best possible light. Ultimately, being well-prepared and confident will have a much greater impact on your chances of success than the order in which you are interviewed.

How Long After an Interview Should You Hear Back?

The time it takes to hear back after an interview can vary widely depending on the company, the position, and the number of candidates. Generally, you can expect to hear back within one to two weeks, but it may take longer in some cases. If you haven't heard back within this timeframe, it's acceptable to follow up with the employer or your talent consultant to inquire about the status of the hiring process.

To learn more about candidate experience, read our blog here.

Why Choose Us?

At Selby Jennings, our team of experts are dedicated to providing you with the latest insights, tips, and advice to help you succeed in your job search with us. Whether you're looking for guidance on career progression, including the sequential interview approach, resume writing, or salary negotiation, we're here to support you every step of the way.

Explore our broad range of jobs available.

Get in Touch Now

Ready to take your career to the next level? Submit your resume today and discover relevant roles. Contact ustoday to learn more about our services and how we can help you achieve your career goals.

Do Employers Interview Best Candidates First? (2024)

FAQs

Is it better to be the first or last candidate interviewed? ›

If an interview process takes place over many months, you may benefit from being the last candidate. In a long process, hiring managers may better recall positive skills and attributes of candidates they see recently rather than ones they haven't interviewed for a long time.

Do top candidates get interviewed first? ›

Some hiring managers may choose to interview the strongest candidates first. This can be advantageous for a number of reasons. By interviewing the top candidate early, employers can gauge other candidates' performances against the benchmark set by the best candidate.

Do interviewers tell successful candidates first? ›

Usually, the successful candidate is notified first by phone. The recruitment manager or the person who interviewed them will phone them to let them know they have been successful and that they are being offered the job. The candidate will usually be asked to confirm their acceptance.

Which type of interview takes place first? ›

First interview: The in-person interviews usually begin with a one-on-one interview with the hiring manager. During this initial meeting, the interviewer typically asks questions about the candidate's qualifications, skills, work history and relevant experience.

Which interview slot is best? ›

Try to select an interview slot for midmorning or early afternoon. If you can't reschedule for the following week, consider signing up for an available interview slot for the midmorning or early afternoon on a Monday or Friday.

Does interview order mean anything? ›

The order in which candidates are interviewed can sometimes be perceived as a reflection of their potential or priority in the eyes of the employer. However, this perception isn't always accurate or beneficial in understanding one's standing in the recruitment process.

How do you know if you're a top candidate? ›

How Do You Know If You Are a Top Candidate? Clear interest from the interviewer, positive body language, and in-depth discussions about the role and company indicate that you are being considered a top candidate.

How many candidates usually make it to the final interview? ›

79.3% of applicants never get an interview. And only 2.5% of candidates make it to the final interview. Moral of the story: make interviews count when you get them!

How to tell if an interview went well? ›

11 Signs your interview went well
  1. You were in the interview for longer than expected. ...
  2. The interview felt conversational. ...
  3. You are told what you would be doing in this role. ...
  4. The interviewer seemed engaged. ...
  5. You feel sold on the company and the role. ...
  6. Your questions are answered in full.

How fast do interviewers decide? ›

Although the interviewers certainly reported making some snap decisions (4.9 per cent of decisions were made within one minute; about 30 per cent within 5 minutes), the vast majority (69.9 per cent) occurred after five minutes or longer.

Do people get hired right after an interview? ›

While there's no one-size-fits-all answer, many employers aim to extend job offers within one to two weeks after the final interview. This allows time for the interviewers to evaluate all candidates and for HR to complete any necessary paperwork.

How do you know if an interviewer is impressed? ›

How to know if an interview went well
  1. Your conversation used the allotted amount of time. ...
  2. You met other team members. ...
  3. They tried to sell you on the role. ...
  4. They asked for your preferred start date. ...
  5. Your interviewers responded positively. ...
  6. They gave you a follow-up date. ...
  7. They asked about other positions. ...
  8. You have a good feeling.
Nov 16, 2022

What is the first line in an interview? ›

To introduce yourself professionally in an interview, start with a polite greeting, state your full name, mention your educational background and relevant work experience, highlight key skills and strengths, briefly share your career objective, and express gratitude for the opportunity.

How many applicants get first interview? ›

"It takes between 1-100 applications to get an interview. Job seekers who sent between 1-10 applications have a 61.7% of getting at least one interview, while those who sent 81 or more applications have an 85.2% chance. The sweet spot, however, seems to be between 21-80 applications.

What is the proper sequence of an interview? ›

Any job interview can be broken down into four general stages: introductions, broad questions and answers, position-related questions, and the conclusion. Take a look at some of our sample interview questions and questions you can ask an interviewer.

What is more important initial or final interview? ›

Companies tend to use final interviews to ask any remaining questions and determine who among the finalists would be the best fit for the role, the team, and the company. That's why it's so important to prepare for a final interview as you would any other interviews you've participated in.

Is going first in an interview best? ›

The Case for Interviewing First

It can work to your advantage to set the bar high and create a very favorable impression. Candidates in the first interviewee position may also benefit from following up after the interview. You can introduce questions that you didn't get a chance to during the formal interview.

Is it better to interview first or last residency? ›

Use your first interviews as warm-ups to your more important interviews. Also, try not to schedule your most important interviews too late into the process. As you near the end of the interview trail, you will likely tire of the entire process, and you want to be at your very best for your most key program interviews.

Is it good or bad when an interview ends early? ›

If your interview ended earlier than scheduled, it may signify that the recruiter made an early decision to move on to the next candidate. If the interviewer seemed rushed, apologised for cutting the interview short and proposed to reschedule, they're probably still interested in getting to know you better.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Horacio Brakus JD

Last Updated:

Views: 5728

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Horacio Brakus JD

Birthday: 1999-08-21

Address: Apt. 524 43384 Minnie Prairie, South Edda, MA 62804

Phone: +5931039998219

Job: Sales Strategist

Hobby: Sculling, Kitesurfing, Orienteering, Painting, Computer programming, Creative writing, Scuba diving

Introduction: My name is Horacio Brakus JD, I am a lively, splendid, jolly, vivacious, vast, cheerful, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.