Should I pay off my debt or save for emergencies first? (2024)

Should I pay off my debt or save for emergencies first? (1)

Three simple ways to pay off credit card debt

Why do financial experts recommend creating an emergency fund before paying off credit card debt?—Brandon

You have some credit card debt and you're up for doing the hard work of paying it off. Then along come financial experts who tell you: Hold on! Emergency fund first!

But why wouldn't you pay off debt as quickly as possible, especially when the average credit card charges a 16.73% interest rate?

"Because life happens," says Rey Cruz, a certified financial planner with Cruz Investments and Wealth Management in Aurora, Illinois.

And relying on a credit card in an emergency is incredibly expensive. In addition to the cost of borrowing, it isn't a safe fallback, says Cruz. "You can't extend your credit if the credit you have is maxed out or no good."

In a perfect world, the best approach is to build a massive emergency fund first and then dispatch your debt. But life is rarely that tidy and everyone's financial picture is different. Cruz's advice for staring down debt and an empty reserve fund is to tackle them both together, bit by bit.

"You need to be contributing to both," says Cruz. "It is difficult and it is more work, but necessary."

Here's how to build up that emergency fund while knocking down your credit card debt.

Skip the 'budget,' and make a 'spending plan'

Before you can decide how much to put toward your debt and how much goes into the emergency fund each pay period, you need to get a handle on your income and expenses.

But don't call it a budget.

"I don't like the word budget," says Cruz. "The first month you do it, you're feeling good. Then your water heater breaks so you have to pay for that and the budget is blown. The next month you need a battery or alternator for your car. You blow it up every month. That's when people say, 'Forget the budget. It never works.' "

Instead, he says, you need to have a spending plan that shows how much is coming in and how much is going out. You're in trouble if more is going out. If your plan can't absorb an emergency (and 40% of American's can't cover an unexpected $400 expense) you need to decrease your expenses or increase your income, to build up your reserve.

Cruz recommends a simple task. Write down everything you've spent money on during a pay period and identify your fixed and variable expenses. You will see if your expenses are more than your income.

Now you can determine how much you can put toward your debt and your emergency fund.

Set up an emergency fund

"The experts will tell you to have three to six months of funds set aside for an emergency," says Cruz. "But I don't always agree with the experts."

Everyone's situation is different, he adds, and the amount of money one person needs to endure a job loss may be vastly different from someone else.

Should I pay off my debt or save for emergencies first? (2)

Of course, emergencies aren't limited to income loss. Perhaps you or a loved one gets sick and can 't work. Or you have to get out of a cohabitating relationship and need a lump sum of money to move immediately.

Whatever the situation, the most important thing is that this money is available to you immediately without having to pay a fee. That means you're not taking it out of a life insurance policy, a 401(k) or selling off stock.

"You have to understand that this fund is not for growth," says Cruz. It's for peace of mind.

Don't let up on debt payments

Even as you put money in an emergency fund, continue to pay down the credit card debt.

"Maybe you are spending way too much money," Cruz says "If your expenses are too high on variable stuff — going out and eating out too much — you need to cut back and sacrifice."

Cruz suggests considering getting an additional job or side gig and putting all of that money toward the debt.

Generally, if you have a total of $1,000 a month coming in and you know (because you've made a spending plan) that your expenses are $800 a month, you can see you've got $200 left.

Maybe you throw $100 at the emergency fund and $100 to debt, says Cruz. Or to move one along a little faster you could put $50 in the emergency fund and $150 toward the debt. But a little should go to each one.

"It may take sacrifice and hard work to get out of debt and build up your emergency fund," says Cruz, "but it is a simple process."

Have a question for Money Moves? Share it with us here and you might be featured in an upcoming column.

CNNMoney (New York) First published June 7, 2018: 12:29 PM ET

Should I pay off my debt or save for emergencies first? (2024)

FAQs

Should I pay off my debt or save for emergencies first? ›

Paying a mortgage, auto loans and other debts that keep a roof over your head should always be your top priority. Never skip minimum monthly payments on debt in order to grow your emergency funds.

Should I save for an emergency fund or pay off debt first? ›

Start by building your emergency fund

Regardless of whether you have debt and how much debt you have, building your emergency fund should be your very first goal.

Should I save or clear debt first? ›

You'll rarely be able to earn more on your savings than you'll pay on your borrowings. So plan to pay off your debts before you start to save. Make sure you understand what interest you're paying on your different loans, so you know which ones you're paying more for.

Is it better to pay off debt or save for a down payment? ›

Because lenders use credit scores to help them evaluate the risk of lending money, a lower credit typically signals that a borrower has had difficulty managing debt repayment in the past. If you have a low credit score due to your debt, you may want to prioritize paying down your debt before saving for a home.

Should I save and pay off debt or just pay off debt? ›

You Need Savings for Emergencies and to Get Out of Debt

Although it makes financial sense to pay off your higher interest rate debt instead of funneling all your money into savings, any short-term gains will be lost if you revert back to credit to cover the cost of emergencies and unplanned expenses.

Should I dump my savings to pay off debt? ›

“Every single day your high-interest debt goes unpaid, it's costing you money — a LOT of money — in interest,” Krawcheck says. Instead of putting your extra cash toward an emergency fund, she suggests that focusing all of it on credit card debt first will save you more in the long run.

What is the 50 30 20 rule? ›

The 50-30-20 rule recommends putting 50% of your money toward needs, 30% toward wants, and 20% toward savings. The savings category also includes money you will need to realize your future goals.

How much money should I save before paying off debt? ›

With no emergency savings to draw on during a crisis, you may have to rely on a high-interest credit card or a personal loan to cover the costs. To avoid compounding your debt, try to set aside between three- and six months' worth of expenses in an emergency fund in a high-interest savings account.

Is it better to pay off debt or save in a recession? ›

If you have an emergency fund saved, you're probably ready to prioritize paying off debt during a recession. When it comes to paying down debt during a recession, you want to focus on your highest interest debt first – things like payday loans and credit cards are a good place to start.

Is 5k a lot of debt? ›

$5,000 in credit card debt can be quite costly in the long run. That's especially the case if you only make minimum payments each month. However, you don't have to accept decades of credit card debt.

How to aggressively pay off debt? ›

What's the best way to pay off debt?
  1. The snowball method. Pay the smallest debt as fast as possible. Pay minimums on all other debt. Then pay that extra toward the next largest debt. ...
  2. Debt avalanche. Pay the largest or highest interest rate debt as fast as possible. Pay minimums on all other debt. ...
  3. Debt consolidation.
Aug 8, 2023

Why is paying off debt bad? ›

Creditors like to see that you can responsibly manage different types of debt. Paying off your only line of installment credit reduces your credit mix and may ultimately decrease your credit scores. Similarly, if you pay off a credit card debt and close the account entirely, your scores could drop.

Is it better to pay off debt all at once or slowly? ›

Paying your entire debt by the due date spares you from interest charges on your balance. Paying off your credit card debt in full also helps keep a lower credit utilization ratio, which measures the amount of your available revolving credit you're using.

Is it better to invest or pay off debt first? ›

A general rule of thumb to consider is that if your expected rate of return on investments is lower than the interest rate on your debt, you should pay down debt first.

Should I have an emergency fund or pay off my house? ›

You might want to establish the security of an emergency fund to hedge against an ailing economy and to pay your mortgage should you experience financial distress. You might want to save for retirement instead, although this involves investing, too, such as in an IRA or 401(k).

When you pay down debt which should you do first? ›

Prioritizing debt by interest rate.

This repayment strategy, sometimes called the avalanche method, prioritizes your debts from the highest interest rate to the lowest. First, you'll pay off your balance with the highest interest rate, followed by your next-highest interest rate and so on.

Should you pay off smallest debt first or highest interest rate? ›

You should first pay off debt with the highest interest rate if your goal is to save money. This approach is known as the debt avalanche method. As of the first quarter of 2024, the average annual percentage rate (APR) on credit cards was over 22%, according to the Federal Reserve.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Barbera Armstrong

Last Updated:

Views: 5971

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Barbera Armstrong

Birthday: 1992-09-12

Address: Suite 993 99852 Daugherty Causeway, Ritchiehaven, VT 49630

Phone: +5026838435397

Job: National Engineer

Hobby: Listening to music, Board games, Photography, Ice skating, LARPing, Kite flying, Rugby

Introduction: My name is Barbera Armstrong, I am a lovely, delightful, cooperative, funny, enchanting, vivacious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.