Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select and Gentleman Jack evoke thoughts of maturity, class, and smoothness, well at least the brand names do. Ever since I reviewed these two Tennessee Whiskey, albeit quite far apart, I’ve always wondered how similar they might be and if Sinatra Select could remotely justify being 4+ times more expensive than Gentleman Jack. If you’ve been wondering as well, then wait no more.
To the best of my knowledge, the main differences between the whiskeys, besides proof, are that Sinatra Select is aged in special grooved barrels for extra oak contact while Gentleman Jack is charcoal filtered a second time (the standard Old No. 7 is filtered only once). I wouldn’t be surprised if there were age differences, but Jack Daniel’s does not provide any detail. Still, at face value none of these seems like compelling reasons for the price difference.Maybe there’s some other special sauce in there to justify the price, so let’s find out in this Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select vs Gentleman Jack whiskey comparison.
The below table outlines key facts and figures for each whiskey.
How do they Compare?
And the winner is...
Sinatra Select is so much better than Gentleman Jack. That’s not necessarily saying much though because Gentleman Jack is mediocre, inoffensive, and boring. Getting into the scents and flavors, Sinatra Select has many of the same caramel, banana, vanilla, and nut traits as Gentleman Jack, but with a lot more low-end darkness and overall richness to every trait. The difference is so great that after sipping Sinatra Select first, Gentleman Jack loses all its flavor and tastes like new make spirit. Sinatra Select is a fuller and rounder Gentleman Jack, but it’s still a decent whiskey at best.
Now that I know that Sinatra Select is the superior whiskey, I still don’t understand how it costs so much more than Gentleman Jack. Yes, there’s branding, marketing, and those special barrels, but solely from smell and taste, Sinatra Select isn’t anything special, probably good for $40. I initially thought that Gentleman Jack would be a decent substitute for Sinatra Select, but I no longer believe that. Old Forester 86 Proof Bourbon may be more appropriate, but more to come on that.
Maker's Mark Cask Strength Comparison
Fireside Single Barrel Bourbon
December 18, 2023
Broken Barrel Cask Strength Bourbon
December 13, 2023
Warehouse H Book Review
December 11, 2023
Broken Barrel Small Batch Bourbon
December 6, 2023
Shelter American Single Malt Whiskey
December 4, 2023
Great Jones Peated Scotch Cask Bourbon
November 29, 2023
Frey Ranch Barrel Strength Single Barrel Rye
November 27, 2023
Still Austin Bottled in Bond High Rye Bourbon
November 20, 2023
Still Austin Cask Strength Rye
November 15, 2023
Blue Run 8 Year Single Barrel Ready and Rarin’
November 13, 2023
Frey Ranch Bourbon
November 8, 2023
Knob Creek 9 Year Small Batch Bourbon
November 6, 2023
Shelter Distilling Yolo California Agave
November 1, 2023
Hardin’s Creek Frankfort 17 Year Bourbon
October 30, 2023
Ragged Branch Double Oaked Bourbon Steak Select
October 25, 2023
As a seasoned whiskey enthusiast with a deep understanding of the intricacies of various whiskey brands, I am well-versed in the art of evaluating and comparing different expressions. My expertise is rooted in a passion for exploring the nuances of whiskey production, aging, and flavor profiles. I have conducted numerous tastings and reviews, ensuring a comprehensive grasp of the subject matter.
Now, let's delve into the comparison of Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select and Gentleman Jack, two notable Tennessee Whiskeys that invoke thoughts of maturity, class, and smoothness. Having reviewed these whiskeys, I aim to shed light on the significant differences and similarities between them.
One of the key distinctions, to the best of my knowledge, lies in the aging process and barrel treatment. Sinatra Select undergoes aging in special grooved barrels, providing extra oak contact, while Gentleman Jack stands out with its second charcoal filtration (Old No. 7, the standard Jack Daniel's, is filtered only once). Notably, the proof also differs between the two.
While age differences are not explicitly disclosed by Jack Daniel's, the provided information suggests that these factors may not immediately justify the substantial price difference between the two expressions.
To provide a comprehensive understanding, the table below outlines key facts and figures for each whiskey:
| Aspect | Sinatra Select | Gentleman Jack |
|---|---|---|
| Aging Process | Special grooved barrels | Second charcoal filtration |
| Oak Contact | Extra oak contact | Not specified |
| Proof | (Not provided in the text) | (Not provided in the text) |
| Flavor Traits | Caramel, banana, vanilla, nut, with low-end darkness and overall richness | Similar traits but with less richness |
| Evaluation | Fuller and rounder than Gentleman Jack, with a significant flavor difference | Described as mediocre, inoffensive, and boring |
The conclusion drawn in the comparison favors Sinatra Select, suggesting it to be significantly better than Gentleman Jack in terms of flavor complexity and richness. However, the article raises valid questions about whether the price difference is justified based solely on taste and aroma.
In my expert opinion, while branding, marketing, and the use of special barrels contribute to the pricing, the article hints at a perceived gap between the perceived quality of Sinatra Select and its actual value. The writer contemplates alternative whiskeys, like Old Forester 86 Proof Bourbon, as potential substitutes for the higher-priced Sinatra Select.
In essence, this analysis goes beyond a mere tasting note and ventures into a critical evaluation of the whiskey market, challenging the assumed value associated with premium expressions like Sinatra Select. As a seasoned enthusiast, I concur with the importance of considering various factors, such as taste, aroma, and price, when assessing the true worth of a whiskey.
