Home Flavor Guide
Flavor Guide
JAMES' FLAVOR GUIDE
Twist wrapped ends are called "tails"
*= Nautral
Salt Water Taffy
- *Banana- yellow with orange tails
- *Cherry- pink with red tails
- *Chocolate- brown with brown tails
- *Cinnamon- white with yellow tails
- Coconut- white with brown tails
- Grape- purple with green tails
- *Lemon- yellow with yellow tails
- Lime- green with green tails
- Licorice- black with red tails
- *Molasses- tan with yellow tails
- *Molasses Mint- tan with orange tails
- *Orange- orange with orange tails
- *Peppermint- white with red tails
- *Strawberry- pink with pink tails
- *Vanilla- white with blue tails
- Wintergreen- white with green tails
Sugar-Free Salt Water Taffy - Currently Not Available
- Banana- yellow
- Chocolate- brown
- Lime- lime green
- Organe- orange
- Peppermint- blue
- Raspberry- pink
- Vanilla- white
Chocolate-Sealed Salt Water Taffy
- Banana- gold foil
- Cherry- cherry and leaf foil
- Chocolate- red foil
- Coconut- dark blue foil
- Orange- orange foil
- Peanut- pink foil
- Peppermint- dark green foil
- Raspberry- purple foil
- Vanilla- light blue foil
Fabulous Salt Water Taffy Flavors
The Tiki Bar:
- Bay Breeze- half pink, half yellow
- Pina Colada- half white, half yellow
From the Fruit Bowl:
- Blueberry- blue with dark blue stripes
- Watermelom- green with pink center
Forbidden Desserts:
- Cookies 'n' Cream- brown with white stripes
- Peanut Butter Cup- chocolate with peanut butter center
Snack Time:
- Peanut Butter & Jelly- tan with peanut butter and jelly center
- Candy Apple- half pink, half white
Pucker Them Lips:
- Sour Apple- apple green
- Sour Grape- purple
- Sour Cherry- pinkish red
Filled Center Salt Water Taffy
- Chocolate- with fudge center
- Lemon- with jelly center
- Banana- with nut center
- Orange- with coconut center
Rum & Butter Toffee
- Rum Toffee- red wax paper
- Butter Toffee- yellow wax paper
FRALINGER'S FLAVOR GUIDE
Salt Water Taffy
- Banana- yellow with brown stripe
- Chocolate- chocolate brown
- Lemon- lemon yellow
- Lime- lime green
- Licorice- gray
- Molasses- tan
- Molasses Mint- tan with brown stripe
- Orange- orange
- Peach- peach with red stripe
- Peanut Butter- white with a peanut center
- Peppermint- white with blue stripes
- Root Beer- white with brown stripes
- Strawberry- strawberry pink
- Teaberry- white with red stripes
- Vanilla- white
Sugar-Free Salt Water Taffy - Currently Not Available
- Banana- yellow
- Chocolate- brown
- Lime- lime green
- Organe- orange
- Peppermint- blue
- Raspberry- pink
- Vanilla- white
Chocolate-Sealed Salt Water Taffy
- Banana- gold foil
- Cherry- cherry and leaf foil
- Chocolate- red foil
- Coconut- dark blue foil
- Orange- orange foil
- Peanut- pink foil
- Peppermint- dark green foil
- Raspberry- purple foil
- Vanilla- light blue foil
Fabulous Salt Water Taffy Flavors
The Tiki Bar:
- Bay Breeze- half pink, half yellow
- Pina Colada- half white, half yellow
From the Fruit Bowl:
- Blueberry- blue with dark blue stripes
- Watermelom- green with pink center
Forbidden Desserts:
- Cookies 'n' Cream- brown with white stripes
- Peanut Butter Cup- chocolate with peanut butter center
Snack Time:
- Peanut Butter & Jelly- tan with peanut butter and jelly center
- Candy Apple- half pink, half white
Pucker Them Lips:
- Sour Apple- apple green
- Sour Grape- purple
- Sour Cherry- pinkish red
Filled Center Salt Water Taffy
- Chocolate- with fudge center
- Lemon- with jelly center
- Banana- with nut center
- Orange- with coconut center
Rum & Butter Toffee
- Rum Toffee- red wax paper
- Butter Toffee- yellow wax paper
Brand Histories
James' Original de Luxe Confections
A confectioner by trade, Enoch James had been tinkering with a recipe for Salt Water Taffy for years...
Bayard's Chocolates
The legend of Bayard's Chocolates began back in 1939 when James Bayard Kelly II created his first batch...
Fralinger's Salt Water Taffy
While the origins of Salt Water Taffy remain a mystery, one thing is for certain. No one did more...
