Do Kamado-style grills pass the taste test? (2024)

Do Kamado-style grills pass the taste test? (1)

Published: Apr. 29, 2019 at 5:52 PM CDT

When you hear Big Green Egg, do you think - Dr. Seuss or a great type of grill?

For over 30 years grill enthusiasts have obsessed over this egg-shaped grill, called Kamado-style. Now - there are some new eggs in town.

Consumer Reports put them through their rigorous tests and found you don't have to break the bank to get a good egg.

Kamado grills are a combination of a charcoal grill, smoker, and outdoor oven. Ryan Markowitz loves what it does for meats.

"It definitely makes it juicier, things don't dry out, you can maintain the temperature and everything is just tastier," Markowitz said.

Their airtight design gives them the ability to deliver controlled heat - extremely high for searing, or low and steady for smoking meats.

Consumer Reports tested eight Kamado grills that you'll see in your home center, wholesale club or hardware store.

You can pay from $300 to almost $2,000 for one of these grills. There are heavy ceramic models and lighter steel versions. Which ones did best in CR tests ranging from grilling pizzas to slow cooking roasts?

Topping CR's list - the Kamado Joe Classic II features a spring-assisted lid that makes it easy to lift open. The upper and lower dampers adjust easily, and split racks let you cook at different heights.

Testers give it excellent marks for cooking performance. It costs $1,300.

The Vision Kamado Professional also got an excellent score for cooking. It has two lower dampers for fine-tuning temperature. The Vision is $700 and comes in five colors.

For just $400, Char-Broil introduced their first Kamado. The Kamander. And it got high marks for cooking, convenience and cleaning. It's made of double-walled stainless steel with a powder-coated finish. Airflow is controlled with upper and lower dampers. It can get to 1000 degrees, charring pizza crust to perfection.

Consumer Reports advises that no matter what type of grill you buy, be it an egg-style or gas or charcoal - don't just look it over in the store. Grasp the handle and give it a shake. Open up the shelves too, and check if the grill feels like it's built to last. Does it seem like it will be easy to maintain, or do you have to get way underneath it to reach the ash pan?

In addition to cooking well your grill should be a pleasure to use.

Do Kamado-style grills pass the taste test? (2024)

FAQs

Does food taste better on kamado? ›

The innovative shape and air-circulating design of the kamado creates a moist cooking environment that will produce tender, flavorful meats.

Is a kamado grill better than a regular grill? ›

Kamado grills, like the Big Green Egg, allow you to cook over a wood fire and give a unique and unmatched taste to your meals. It does take a little time to learn and can be a bit more expensive than a gas grill, but the results will be worth it.

What makes kamado grills so good? ›

Because of the airtight seal and the high mass of the kamado, the temperature is maintained well and there is no unnecessary air circulation in the BBQ. All the air you allow through the vents is fully used to maintain the desired temperature.

Is a kamado a good smoker? ›

Kamados can be used for smoking and grilling. Baking, too! Ceramic models are fantastic at temperature retention, which is ideal for smoking at a low, set temp. But pile on the fuel, open the dampers, and they'll get screaming hot—perfect for searing.

What's the difference between kamado and Big Green Egg? ›

Kamado Joe grills come with multiple racks and tools for easy manoeuvring of the hot racks. However, the BGE grills only come with grilling gates that are at a singular height. So, although you can move the plates and grates to alter the height of the food slightly, there's comparatively less flexibility.

Is a kamado BBQ worth it? ›

A ceramic kamado is great if you want great juicy meat every time. As well as being extremely effective at controlling the temperature, the kamado is also amazing at retaining the moisture to help ensure your food doesn't dry out. This is extremely beneficial when doing longer low temperature cooks on your kamado.

Are kamado grills good for pizza? ›

More and more people are discovering they can cook pizza on kamado-style grills. Their ability to maintain high temperatures and radiate heat from above and below make them a great option for wood-fired pizza cooking without a wood-fired pizza oven.

How long do kamado grills last? ›

A Kamado Joe will last a lifetime!

You can count on the very best warranty!

Can you use wood instead of charcoal in a Kamado grill? ›

A: Absolutely. It will withstand a wood fire, as charcoal gets much hotter than wood, hence its widespread use in the first place. I would recommend cutting the wood into manageable hunks and starting with a charcoal base, but you'll find what works for you.

Why are kamados so expensive? ›

Ceramic is expensive to produce, so kamado grills are on the expensive side. Preheating a kamado grill takes a while.

What is the best fuel for a kamado grill? ›

In the debate between lump charcoal and briquettes, we believe that lump charcoal is far superior for grilling. Some of the benefits of lump charcoal include: All-natural fuel. Burns hotter.

Are kamado grills good for burgers? ›

The absolute must from a food hygiene perspective is that a burger should be cooked through and the technical capability of a kamado makes it just that little bit easier. If you have a two zone oval kamado then set it up with one heat deflector stone so that you can cook both directly and indirectly as shown below.

Why get a ceramic grill? ›

Efficiency Redefined: How Ceramic Grills Enhance Cooking

The heat is distributed symmetrically and there are no cold spots inside of the big eggs. Once your ceramic Kamado is hot - it stays hot and helps you save on charcoal. Use less charcoal and cook more food - the math is simple!

Are kamado grills easy to clean? ›

Cleaning the interior of your kamado grill is easy because it works like a self-cleaning oven: Heat the grill to +600 for 30 minutes and allow the grill to cool completely. Remove the internal components of the grill. Use a soft bristle brush to brush the interior of the grill.

Why does my food taste of smoke on Big Green Egg? ›

One thing I can think of may be the amount of time from lighting the charcoal to putting the food on. Is the BGE and the charcoal really ready when you're at your desired temperature?

Does wood make food taste better? ›

In addition to providing heat, wood can add rich, complex flavors to food. These flavors are often more intense and distinctive than those from other cooking methods. Wood-fired cooking is a product of the unique chemical properties of wood and its ability to release high levels of heat.

Is kamado good for pizza? ›

A kamado/ceramic grill allows cooking over a real wood fire and it gives you the control you need to cook at higher temperatures. These are perfect attributes for pizza.

What cuts of meat are good for Kamado grill? ›

Top rounds, chuck roasts and even ribs are on the list. Really, any large cut of beef would do well, with or without smoke added. For these cuts, lower temperature is key. Using the Saffire as a smoker grill is great for low temperature cooking.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kerri Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 6005

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kerri Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1992-10-31

Address: Suite 878 3699 Chantelle Roads, Colebury, NC 68599

Phone: +6111989609516

Job: Chief Farming Manager

Hobby: Mycology, Stone skipping, Dowsing, Whittling, Taxidermy, Sand art, Roller skating

Introduction: My name is Kerri Lueilwitz, I am a courageous, gentle, quaint, thankful, outstanding, brave, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.